Okay, I am so excited to be writing this review. Coach Me by Mollie Goins was incredible and nearly impossible to put down.
I read Pitcher Us through LoveNotesPR earlier this year and simply fell in love with Goins’s writing style. Every character has been so well thought out and articulated in such a way that makes them fly off the page. If you follow my Bookstagram (@ejreads if you don’t) you’ll know I am a Will Anderson fan girl. Now, I fear I am a fan girl for the whole Anderson family after reading about Lucie.
Disclaimer: If there is one thing about me, it’s that I don’t like kids in my romance. I never have and I don’t know if I ever will. It’s just not my personal taste. So, my experience is limited in the single dad x nanny tropes. However, I loved this book enough that it didn’t make me a believer, but it did give me an understanding of why people like it.
Okay let’s get to it:
Coach Me is the second installment of the Boston Blues series that follows interconnected stories about baseball players and their families. Dex Larson is only a year into retirement from pitching and a year into coaching when his systems begin to break down. Going from playing to coaching was one thing, but adding in a divorce and full custody of his firecracker 5 year old Miles, he is being run ragged. Season is coming soon, and as little as he wants to admit it, he needs help. Lucie Anderson, sister to starting pitcher Will Anderson of the Boston Blues, just finished her first year teaching and loves what she does. Her first year couldn’t have gone better and she is ready to get a jump on planning for the next year when she is let go the first Monday into summer break. Now she is 24, has a degree but no job prospects, and her sister has announced she is moving out of their shared apartment at the end of the summer. When Callie, Will’s girlfriend and team photographer, hears about this, it sounds to her like Dex and Lucie can help each other out.
Lucie Anderson, I want to be your best friend. She is the golden retriever best friend that my black cat-ness needs. Being the youngest, she feels a certain responsibility to find herself and not let anyone down, namely her siblings who worked so hard to get her where she is. This led to a pretty severe loss of self because she seemed to feel like she just owed them everything. Being 24, it’s a hard age to be where you feel like you’re playing dress-up as a grown up with their life together. She was just a beautifully complex character and I would die for her.
Let’s talk about Dex and Miles. Dex puts the grumpy in grumpy x sunshine. But what I love and appreciate about Dex is that he is aware of the situation. He knows Lucie is younger than him and he doesn’t want to pressure her at all. He is aware that it is a cliche to fall in love with the nanny, and he owns it. He makes sure that Lucie is his priority as much as he can while keeping Miles at the forefront always. That’s what I think I love about them. Miles didn’t feel like an accessory to their story. He was a main character as much as Lucie and Dex were. Their love for him was completely independent of their love for each other, and it showed in every action.
This is one of the stories that, yes there is plot and an overall story that is incredibly well-written and developed, but the characters are what make it shine. The characters are what come to mind because they make it real.
I can’t wait to see the rest of the series play out, and I can’t wait for more Dex and Lucie in future books!
P.S. If you want a sneak peek at some of my favorite quotes from Coach Me – check out my IG post Ranking No Context Coach Me Quotes Through Memes
Thank you, Mollie Goins and LoveNotesPR for gifting me an ARC in exchange for an honest review. Coach Me will be released in stores and on KindleUnlimited on August 15, 2025.
xoxo
ej